the ridiculous pursuit of being well-rounded

Multi-disciplinary, general studies, political correctness, easy to get along with, in moderation, “nice”…these are all ways that we polish off our edges to be socially acceptable and useful - even though it's your edges that give you traction and make you interesting. Your “edge” - where the genuine You meets external reality, is where your strengths are, your genius, and it’s way more fun hanging out there than in the middle ground.

Being well-rounded is highly over-rated.

Employers who are trying to multiply the strengths of people are missing the point. Entrepreneurs trying to do it all are bound to go in circles. When you focus on building on your natural strengths, on doing what comes easiest to you, you get some serious momentum. It may be counter-intuitive, it’s certainly counter-culture because it’s been drilled into to us to work hard (all you Catholics and Ivy Leaguers say hey!) but truly, optimizing your second nature is the surest way to get a return on your investment.

Ever since I read Markus Buckingham’s The Truth About You, I’ve been stopping strangers on the street. “Hey, get this. You know what a strength is? A strength is what you do that makes you feels strengthened, vital! And…wait, it gets better, you know what a weakness is? A weakness is stuff you do that makes you feel weakened!

Deceptively simple. Revolutionary.

Why does this make me wanna do back-flips? Because this changes everything, people. And it goes back to my root theory in life, that it’s all about feelings. It means that all that crap that you don’t really like to do, but that you’re really good at – you get to dump it! No more faking it to make it.

So what about good old-fashioned hard work? I’m all for it - when you’re moving towards the real you. No more trying to be a PR genius when what you do best is paint landscapes or make the widgets (hire a PR genius.) No more trying to come up with blue sky five year plans when you’re a short-term focused details guy (get a coach or a visionary friend to help you see the possibilities.) For me, that means I will never care about cooking the Thanksgiving turkey, being good at parties, or rocking Excel. Never gonna happen.

THE STRONG / WEAK EXERCISE
Buckingham has a powerful exercise that I loved. For one week I wrote down what made me feel strong and what made me feel weakened/drained. This showed up on my "weak" list: unqualified meetings make me feel like a loogan.

I was scheduled to have tea with an acquaintance of an acquaintance. I trusted the referral and so I made the date in haste, with a quick “sure, how about the café by so and so’s.”

A few weeks later when I was walking to the meeting, I was feeling really resentful and pissy. WEAKENED. Because I hadn’t bothered to ask, I had no idea why the person actually wanted to meet. And I was feeling like I’d betrayed my time, my priorities. (And sure enough, the meeting could have happened in 15 minutes over the phone and I wouldn’t have had to find parking or rush to pick up my kid.) Conclusion: I feel strong when I ask, when I clarify, when I know The Point. I feel weak when don’t value my own time.

The masters focus on what they do best – on their NATURAL CAPACITIES. They stay in their zone – and the zone is what feels good, damn good.

So I what makes you feel strong?
Do more of it. And more still. Find ways to get even better at it, sharpen your saw as the old master of effectiveness, Stephen Covey puts it. Push your edge. Dare to be focused on your natural capacities. Say yes to what you love, what inspires you, what lights you up. It takes some kahunas, but it beats well-rounded mediocrity any day.

. . . . . . . .

FIND MARCUS BUCKINGHAM
His site
The Truth About You
Now, Discover Your Strengths
Twitter: @mwbuckingham

23 comments so far. add your own.

 

Danielle,

I know particularly well how horrible it is to be 'well-rounded', because I suffer from this disorder. Allow me to explain.

As a 'liberal arts' graduate, I majored in a ton of different things, ranging from computer information systems to English to vocal performance. I never have been able to find my niche.

Employers do not take nicely to this. They want people who do specific things amazingly well. Not employers who do a lot of things pretty good.

What advice do you give to those who love learning everything? Should we pick something, or find a way to make it all work to our advantage?

 
     

    Jeffrey, you might take a liking to Barbara Sher's "Refuse to Choose." She puts a positive spin on what it is to be a renaissance soul, which she calls "scanners." Her tone is not only unapologetic, but even a little evangelical... in a "don't you wish you could be as wide and varied as me?" kinda way. Very dignifying stuff ;-)

    I don't know if this link will go live, but (fingers crossed) here's an extended excerpt from Google books. I think lots of WHT readers might resonate:

    http://books.google.com/books?id=xGVRPZA238sC&dq=refuse+to+choose&printsec=frontcover&source=bn&hl=en&ei=Ja7lSujqA4u4M8m0hZ8D&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=5&ved=0CBcQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=&f=false

     
     

    I think the operative phrase here is "love to learn everything." So, you're a learner. the research, likely, the connector of concepts, fact, trivia, ideas. You're the guy to have on the team at the beginning of any project. THAT's the strength - and it can be applied to any industry. Trick is to find an employer who hires for the strength (the person) and not necessarily the skill.

     
     

    Step back from your skill set and interest group and ask yourself what they have in common...In my opinion, there is a common thread that binds all the learning and activities, interests that you have pursued over the years. Find that thread, and that is what you do- that is what you are an expert in. Promote that!


    Darci Rowe
    30 Oct 09
     
 

This is genius. Such a simple concept but your way with words always makes things just punch me in the face (in a good way if that's possible). I appreciate your blog for always giving concrete ideas on how to live consciously and work towards a better self. I found you through Style Statement and just recently, after leaving my corporate job, found this space of yours. So glad I did. It motivates me and connects me to an inner self I've been neglecting (not my concept - taken from another great blog I can't remember right now). I'll be using the strong/weak exercise over the next few days.

 
 

Danielle, I'm a new reader and the weakness you gave as an example is very true for me, too. Thank you for simplifying for me how much it bothers me when I don't see the point of something that requires my time and presence. Life is way too short not to learn from our weaknesses.

 
 

It puts a whole new light on those classic interview questions - tell me 3 of your strengths, 3 of your weaknesses!!! I'm going to do the strong/weak exercise this week - I can see that being an eye opener and confirming a lot of things to me that, deep down, I already know. It's taken a while but I've discovered lately that being true to your self is the key to pretty much everything, but especially in a work-related situation.

 
 

Wow. Awesome.


Christine
26 Oct 09
 
 

Yes yes yes! Marcus Buckingham is a god in my opinion, I've read nearly everything of his. We're like jigsaw pieces: my shape is severely lacking the administrative talent that enables some people to file their taxes on time, so I pay someone to do that for me. My friend's shape cannot grasp writing, so I draft her business reports for her and she mends and alters my clothes for me. This interdependence is a GOOD thing. It shows us we're fully human, with fully human vulnerabilities and strengths.

 
     

    yeah, I think Marcus is aces. "This interdependence is a GOOD thing." what a lovely layer to this that I hadn't thought of. Make my brain sigh a nice fresh breath of relief and beauty. Thanks for that.

     
 

You're right. A lot of people, myself included, set these strange goals that we think would make us happy, but really just take us off the path. Being real with myself means that I don't have to become an ultrarunner or a musician. Time to focus on the writing and blogging a bit more.

 
 

On behalf of the Ivy Leaguers everywhere :) - Thank you for this brilliant post and this incomparable reminder to be who we are, to do what emboldens us, to ignore the countless voices and the conflicting messages. I am beginning to believe that if we are doing what we should be doing, it should feel easy. It's a process, yes, but I feel myself getting there, slowly but surely.

 
 

Amen. Shout it from the edge of the roof!

 
 

Nail, on the head. AND, if you hire someone else to do all the crap you're a.) not good at and b.) RESENT (for me, it's coding, SEO, and marketing), you're helping someone ELSE do what they're good at and love to do.

 
 

love this post Danielle!


arpen thandi
26 Oct 09
 
 

Danielle,
Good stuff--just what I needed to read today. Seems to be happening alot...and doesn't it just make the most sense ever? I totally get you wanting to stop strangers and get a little Amen! from them.
Take Care,
Jill

 
 

super article. I was told I'd have trouble getting into a top college because I wasn't well rounded enough! Well, I ended up getting into the school that was right for me. Hey, I didn't want to play field hockey! It's the rare person who is naturally "well-rounded" whatever that means. I'm well-trapezoided.

 
 

I spend a lot of time with elite strength people. Men and women who can do things that the human body is not supposed to be able to do. The one thing they all have in common--well, besides psychosis--is that they are each elite at one or two...maybe three things. They can't be good at everything and they don't want to be. They want to be the best and so they are.

I went into librarianship because I like to generalize in terms of knowledge. But when I really want to be good at something, something else has to be excluded.

Danielle, you continue to be the most delightful daffodil on the web.

 
 

Great piece! Those two questions are in my coaching toolkit, alongside What expands you? and What contracts you?

I'm one of those Scanners or renaissance souls Erika mentioned, but there are themes running through all the things I've done in my life. They were never done in some plan to become well rounded and they've all come together to help me coach other Scanners. Again, not a niche I deliberately sought. We're just drawn to each other because of those "Me too!!" moments.

Sher compares Scanners with deep divers, who follow one thing and go deep.

I love your fiery passion when you find things you love and resonate with. We could all do with more of it. I come here hoping that some of it will rub off, seeing as I agree with so much of what you say but seem like such a timid wee mouse compared to you!

 
 

Like Jeffrey I love to learn, but I can don't like to only know one subject. I absord information like a sponge and love that I can provide the information later in a variety of circumstances. But like him I have found it hard to make that translate to my resume so I continue to spin in the cosmic inertia.


Megan DaGata
29 Oct 09
 

share your truth + opinions